Natalie Dee & Drew present to you the bizarre story of Mothman, the legendary West-Virginia-based creature that might be real. Or not real. Maybe he’s real, but constructed by the CIA. We expose the facts, explore all of these theories, and more, right here, right now.

Here’s an illustration of M-Man himself, as drawn by ???? in the year ???? (see, we told you it was mysterious.)

It’s The Smiling Man, aka Indrid Cold, as drawn by someone who saw him, supposedly!

Our friend Elissa, who you’ve heard on our Cemetery and Haunted Prison episodes, took these photos (above) in the Mothman Museum in Point Pleasant, WV. The actual watch and chapstick from the movie Mothman Prophecies! A letter from a Kennedy! And a very nicely made Mothman quilt. It’s the largest collection of Mothman memorabilia in the world.

Want to hear the twenty-plus subscriber-only episodes of Garbage Brain University? Here’s the button you gotta hit:

Subscribe now

Subscribers! Have you been to Point Pleasant? Seen Mothman? Or Indrid Cold? Or another mysterious Appalachian creature or person? Do you want to? Leave us a comment, and read what other Garbage Brain Geniuses have to say:

View comments

You can also listen to Garbage Brain University on Spotify, iTunes, and/or Stitcher if you don’t already! And thanks again to Substack for our podcast/newsletter setup, and to The Melvins for our theme song, “Electric Flower,” used with permission.

natalie & drew

A Plan to Scare Poor People and Measure How …

Create your profile

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Check your email